Most Reliable Used Cars: Toyota, Lexus, Honda, and Acura Stand Out in Consumer Reports Study

When shopping for a pre-owned vehicle, a low price is only part of the value equation. Long-term dependability matters just as much—especially once a vehicle is outside its original warranty period.

Consumer Reports’ latest used-car reliability study puts several Toyota and Honda family brands at the very top. The organization evaluated reliability for vehicles that are approximately five to 10 years old, using owner-reported problems across 20 potential trouble areas.

The result: Lexus ranked No. 1, Toyota ranked No. 2, Honda ranked No. 4, and Acura ranked No. 5 among 26 automotive brands for long-term used-car reliability.

Toyota and Lexus: Leading the Used-Car Reliability Rankings

Consumer Reports placed Lexus first and Toyota second in its 2025 used-car brand reliability rankings. The study examined owner-reported issues involving 2016–2021 model-year vehicles, with more than 140,000 vehicles represented in the survey data.

Toyota and Lexus are known for making measured, incremental changes rather than constantly introducing unproven systems. That approach can be a benefit for used-car shoppers, helping many vehicles remain dependable as they accumulate years and miles.

For drivers looking for a practical sedan, family SUV, hybrid, or truck, Toyota offers a wide variety of options in the pre-owned market. Lexus adds upscale comfort, technology, and refinement while maintaining a reputation for long-term dependability.

Start your search with the inventory at Toyota of Braintree, where you can explore Toyota vehicles that fit your needs, lifestyle, and budget.

Honda and Acura Also Earn Top-Five Recognition

Honda and Acura also performed exceptionally well in Consumer Reports’ long-term reliability analysis. Honda ranked fourth, while Acura ranked fifth among the 26 brands studied.

Honda has long been a popular choice for drivers who want efficient, versatile transportation. From compact cars to family-ready SUVs and minivans, the brand is well represented in the used market. Acura, Honda’s luxury division, brings a more premium driving experience while still offering strong long-term reliability credentials.

For shoppers considering a dependable Honda, Honda of Plymouth is a convenient place to begin exploring available vehicles.

What the Consumer Reports Rankings Actually Measure

It is important to understand that this is a brand-level ranking—not a guarantee that every model or model year will perform identically.

Consumer Reports based its rankings on problems reported by owners of 5- to 10-year-old vehicles. The study considered 20 potential trouble areas, ranging from minor concerns such as interior trim and brakes to more significant issues involving engines, transmissions, batteries, and charging equipment.

The key takeaway for buyers: a strong brand reputation is a useful starting point, but it should be followed by research into the specific model year, vehicle history, maintenance records, recalls, and condition of the individual vehicle you are considering.

Smart Steps Before Buying a Used Toyota or Honda

A reliability ranking can help narrow your shortlist, but a thoughtful used-car purchase should also include:

Reviewing the vehicle-history report for accidents, title issues, and maintenance information.
Confirming that open recalls have been completed.
Looking at service records, especially for higher-mileage vehicles.
Taking a thorough test drive.
Having an independent pre-purchase inspection performed when appropriate.
Comparing the exact model year—not just the model name—because reliability can vary between generations and redesigns.

The Bottom Line

Consumer Reports’ findings give used-car shoppers a clear signal: Toyota, Lexus, Honda, and Acura are among the strongest brands to consider when long-term dependability is a priority.

Lexus and Toyota led the study at No. 1 and No. 2, while Honda and Acura rounded out the top five at No. 4 and No. 5. Whether you are looking for a commuter car, a family SUV, a premium luxury vehicle, or a practical daily driver, these brands offer a compelling foundation for a used-car search.

For the full methodology and current rankings, see Consumer Reports’ used-car reliability report.